Justin of MISSLE AN(e)US wins this one by default since he was the only one to send an entry in.
Even though it was the only entry, it's still a pretty sweet sketch:
Justin wins a shiny new copy of Lovecraft Tales from The Library of America. If any of you want to try for second place send entries to: email@example.com
Oh and Justin, send me your address!
I may try this again sometime next month if I can get more people to participate.